Stop Chasing Every Landlord: How to Decide Which Managements Are Actually Worth Winning

When you're responsible for growing a rent roll, it's easy to fall into the trap of thinking every landlord is a good prospect.

A lead comes in, so you chase it. An appraisal gets booked, so you do everything you can to win it. Someone asks for a management fee, so you send a proposal.

The problem is that not every management is worth winning.

Growing a rent roll isn't just about adding more properties. It's about adding the right properties, with the right landlords, in a way that makes commercial sense for your business and your team.

That means being prepared to qualify an opportunity rather than automatically pursuing every one that comes your way.

More properties doesn't always mean a better portfolio

It's easy to celebrate when a new management comes on.

Another property added to the rent roll. Another fee-paying client. Another number for the monthly growth report.

But what happens after that?

If the property requires constant attention, the landlord expects more than your team can realistically provide, the fee is too low to justify the workload or the property is outside your ideal service area, you've potentially created more work without creating much value.

This is where BDMs need to look beyond the number of properties won.

A 20-property portfolio isn't necessarily better than a 10-property portfolio if those 20 properties consume twice as much time and create twice as many problems.

The quality of the growth matters.

Know what your ideal management looks like

Before you can decide whether a management is worth winning, you need to know what a good management looks like for your business.

That will be different for every agency.

For some, it might be properties in particular suburbs where they have strong local knowledge and a reliable network of trades. For others, it might be investors with multiple properties or landlords who value a more proactive style of management.

Think about the properties and landlords your team works best with.

Which ones are profitable? Which ones are straightforward to manage? Which landlords trust your advice? Which properties fit naturally into your existing portfolio?

Those patterns are useful.

They give you a much clearer definition of an ideal management than simply saying, "We want more properties."

Look at the landlord, not just the property

A beautiful property in a great suburb can still be a difficult management if the landlord relationship isn't right.

Pay attention to how the landlord communicates during the appraisal.

Are they respectful of your time? Are their expectations realistic? Do they listen to professional advice? Are they focused entirely on paying the lowest possible management fee? Do they understand that good property management sometimes involves difficult conversations?

You don't need every landlord to think exactly like you, but there needs to be a reasonable level of trust and alignment.

If the relationship feels difficult before you've even taken the property on, don't assume it will somehow become easier once the management agreement is signed.

Usually, the opposite happens.

Be careful with the "cheap fee" conversation

One of the clearest warning signs is when the entire appraisal revolves around price.

If the first question is, "What is your management fee?" that's fine. It's a legitimate question.

But if the conversation never moves beyond price, you need to understand what you're competing on.

There will always be someone prepared to charge less.

If you win a management by being the cheapest option, you may eventually find yourself in a portfolio full of landlords who are also prepared to leave when someone offers them a slightly lower fee.

That doesn't mean you should refuse price-sensitive landlords. It means you need to consider whether the fee, the expectations and the level of service required make the management commercially worthwhile.

Consider the workload, not just the income

This is particularly important when you're looking at properties that require a high level of involvement.

How much time is this management likely to take?

Is the property older and likely to require more maintenance? Is the landlord highly hands-on? Is there a history of tenant issues? Is the property in an area where inspections and maintenance take more time to coordinate?

None of these things automatically make a property a bad prospect.

But they should form part of the decision.

A management fee needs to make sense against the actual work involved.

If you're adding properties faster than your team can comfortably service them, growth can quickly become a retention problem.

Don't ignore location

Geography matters more than some BDMs realise.

If your team has strong coverage in a particular area, adding another property nearby may be relatively easy to manage. Your property managers already know the suburbs, your trades are familiar with the area and your team isn't spending unnecessary time travelling.

A single property 40 minutes outside your usual service area might look attractive on paper, but you need to consider the operational impact.

Again, it's not necessarily a reason to say no.

It's a reason to ask whether the opportunity fits your business model.

Think about the landlord's future, too

One of the best questions you can ask is:

"What does your property portfolio look like over the next few years?"

You may discover that the landlord you're speaking to owns one property today but plans to purchase several more.

That's a very different opportunity from someone who has one property and intends to sell it within the next 12 months.

Look for landlords who see property as a long-term investment and who value having a strong property management relationship as their portfolio grows.

The first property might be the beginning of a much more valuable relationship.

Don't be afraid to walk away

This is probably the hardest part for a BDM.

When you're under pressure to hit a growth target, saying no to a management can feel like you're leaving money on the table.

But sometimes the best business decision is to walk away.

If the expectations are unrealistic, the relationship feels wrong, the property doesn't fit your service area or the economics simply don't stack up, winning the management won't necessarily be a success.

I'd rather see a BDM build a smaller portfolio of good-quality managements than constantly chase numbers that create problems for the property management team six months later.

The best BDMs aren't just good at winning business.

They're good at identifying which business is worth winning.

Create your own qualification checklist

You don't need a complicated system.

Before pursuing an opportunity, consider a few basics:

Does the property fit our service area?

Does the management fee make commercial sense?

Are the landlord's expectations realistic?

Does the property fit our ideal portfolio?

Is there potential for a longer-term relationship?

Can our team deliver the level of service this landlord expects?

If several answers are no, take a step back before committing your time and resources to winning it.

You may decide it's still worth pursuing, but at least you'll be making that decision intentionally.

Growth should make your business stronger

The goal of business development isn't simply to make the rent roll bigger.

It's to build a portfolio that your team can manage well, that generates healthy revenue and that creates strong, long-term relationships with landlords.

So the next time a new lead comes in, don't immediately ask:

"How do I win this management?"

Ask:

"Is this a management I actually want to win?"

That small change in thinking can have a big impact on the quality of your rent roll.

And when you stop measuring BDM success purely by the number of properties added, you can start building a portfolio that is better for your business, your team and your clients.

Want to build a better rent roll?

If you want to become more strategic about the way you prospect, qualify opportunities and grow your rent roll, work with me.

Because sustainable growth isn't about chasing every landlord.

It's about knowing which ones are worth chasing in the first place.

Lauren Robinson